Online intake

Start a consignment

Tell us about you and your cards and add a few clear photos. Our team will review your request and confirm by email whether we can take on your cards. Please wait for approval and sign your agreement before shipping.

What cards can I consign?

We accept raw and graded sports cards, subject to review. We generally focus on cards with an estimated resale value of $10 or more per card. Have a collection, sealed product or something outside those guidelines? Contact us before shipping so we can confirm whether it’s a fit.

1. Your information

Full name *

Email *Periods and other punctuation are saved exactly as entered.

Confirm email *

Phone *

Preferred contact

How did you hear about us? *

Referred by a consignor?

Referral code (optional)

You and your referrer each earn a $10 bonus after your first $100 in qualifying card sales. New consignors only; one referral per person, no self-referrals or combining with Craig’s offer. Bonuses require Scott’s approval and are paid separately. See the referral rules.

2. Your cards

Approximate number of cards *

Card type

Estimated total value

Describe the cards *

Photos (up to 25)Add card photosJPG, PNG, WEBP or HEIC · 8 MB each · 50 MB total

3. Review and acknowledge

Optional premium Instagram marketing

Final sale priceYou receive

Under $10070%

$100 – $499.9975%

$500+80%

The standard consignment period is 90 days. Cards may be sold through Buy It Now, Best Offer or auction. Payouts are generally made within 14 business days after cleared buyer payment, provided there is no unresolved return, chargeback, marketplace hold or other reversal. All cards are subject to acceptance and the full Scott’s Cards NYC Consignment Agreement.

I understand this is a request for review. No consignment begins unless Scott’s Cards NYC approves the cards and I sign the full Consignment Agreement. I confirm that the information I provided is accurate and that I own or am authorized to consign these items.

Submitting sends your information and photos to Scott’s Cards NYC for review. Do not ship cards until your request is approved and you have signed your agreement.