Personal sports card consignment
Send the cards.
We’ll handle the rest.
We manage every step—from receiving your cards to sending your payout.
Professional card photos
Buy It Now + Best Offer
Personal service from Scott
Secure packing and shipping
Straightforward rates
Consignment payouts
The more your card sells for, the more you keep.
Custom rates may be available for qualifying large or high-value consignments.
Simple from start to payout
How it works
Send your cards
Complete your intake online, then safely pack and ship your cards to us.
We list them
We inventory, photograph and list accepted cards on eBay as Buy It Now listings.
We handle the sale
Buyer questions, payment, authentication, packing and shipping are handled for you.
You get paid
Available proceeds are generally sent electronically within 14 business days.
Collector-run. Personally handled.
A better way to consign
Professional listings
Clear photography, research and accurate descriptions designed to present your cards well.
Established eBay store
Your cards are listed through Scott’s Cards NYC for access to active collectors.
Secure handling
We manage packing, tracked shipping and eBay authentication when applicable.
Transparent payouts
Your sale summary shows the final price, payout rate, authorized adjustments and net amount.
Ship with confidence
How to send your cards
Complete the online intake first. Protect raw cards in clean penny sleeves and properly sized top loaders. Leave graded cards in their slabs and protect them from scratching.
- Use a sturdy corrugated box with cushioning on every side.
- Keep cards from sliding; never tape directly to cards or holders.
- Use tracking and keep your receipt until delivery is confirmed.
- Insurance is strongly recommended for higher-value submissions.
Good to know
Frequently asked questions
How long is the consignment period?+
The standard consignment period is 90 days from our documented receipt of your cards, unless another period is agreed to in writing.
Can I set a minimum price?+
Yes. Add a minimum acceptable sale price to your intake. We will not complete a sale below it without your approval.
Are cards sold at auction?+
No. Accepted cards are listed on eBay as Buy It Now / fixed-price listings. Best Offer may be enabled.
How will I get paid?+
Payouts are sent by PayPal, Venmo, Zelle or another agreed electronic method. We do not offer ACH or check payouts.
Do you accept every card?+
All consignments and individual cards are subject to review and acceptance. Contact us before shipping unusually valuable, oversized or sealed items.
Who pays for buyer shipping?+
The buyer pays shipping. Buyer-paid shipping is separate from the card’s final sale price and does not reduce your payout percentage.
Ready when you are
Turn your cards into cash.
Submit your cards for review. We’ll email you after Scott approves your request.